Josh Smith: The Best Smith on Forged in Fire Who Didn't Win'

The history of competitive blacksmithing has seen its fair share of controversies, and the popular History Channel show Forged in Fire is no exception. With eight seasons under its belt, the show has witnessed some remarkable sword-making skills from talented smiths like Josh Smith, who made a name for himself on Season 3 Episode 5: The Kora Sword.

At just 19 years old, Josh was the youngest ABS Master Smith at the time, with an impressive 25 years of experience in crafting exceptional blades. His incredible skills were put to the test as he went up against then-19-year-old wunderkind Liam Hoffman in the finale. In a stunning display, Josh dominated the first two rounds, showcasing his mastery over the craft.

One of the most notable aspects of Josh's Kora Sword was its unique fluting design, which Judge Doug Marcaida praised as 'one of the most visually stunning blades we've ever seen in this forge.' This, combined with its excellent balance and rounded handle that made it roll smoothly in the hand, earned him a spot among the best finale weapons in the show.

Despite his exceptional skills, Josh didn't win the competition. Instead, he took second place to Liam Hoffman's Kora Sword, which was also an impressive piece of craftsmanship. This has led some fans to question the judges' decisions and whether they always choose the best blade. While it's true that there have been instances where runner-ups produced finale weapons far superior to winners in other episodes, it's important to remember that Forged in Fire is a competition format primarily meant for entertainment.

As an avid fan of the show, I've seen every episode up to and including Season 8 Episode 15. In my opinion, Josh Smith remains one of the best smiths on the show who didn't win. His dedication to his craft, combined with his exceptional skills and attention to detail, make him a standout among the many talented blacksmiths featured on Forged in Fire.

In conclusion, Josh Smith's incredible Kora Sword is a testament to his remarkable talent as a blacksmith. While he may not have won the competition, his skills and craftsmanship are undeniable. As fans of the show continue to debate the judges' decisions and the merits of each blade, one thing is clear: Josh Smith is a true master of his craft.

Forged in fire host season 6